Straus Ice Cream Recall 2026: UPC Codes, Dates & Voucher Guide
On May 14, 2026, Straus Family Creamery issued a voluntary recall for specific batches of its organic ice cream. The reason is the potential presence of metal fragments inside the product.
This recall targets five specific flavors sold across 17 states.
If you have Straus ice cream sitting in your freezer right now, do not eat it. Just as importantly, do not pack it up to return to the grocery store. Here is the exact data you need to verify your carton, throw it away safely, and claim your replacement voucher directly from the manufacturer.
Straus Family Creamery is recalling select Pints and Quarts of Vanilla Bean, Strawberry, Cookie Dough, Dutch Chocolate, and Mint Chip ice cream due to potential metal fragments. The affected products were sold in 17 states. Consumers should discard the ice cream and request a replacement voucher online.
Key Takeaways
- 5 flavors affected: Vanilla Bean, Strawberry, Cookie Dough, Dutch Chocolate, and Mint Chip.
- Only specific sizes and “Best By” dates between Dec. 23, 2026, and Dec. 30, 2026, are recalled.
- Products hit store shelves in 17 states starting May 4, 2026.
- Zero injuries have been reported as of mid-May 2026.
- Do not return the ice cream to the store; you must request a manufacturer voucher online.
Quick Start: “Is My Ice Cream Recalled?” Rapid Identification Matrix
Check your freezer. If your exact flavor, size, and date match a row in this table, your ice cream is part of the recall.
| Flavor | Recalled Size | Recalled “Best By” Dates |
| Vanilla Bean | Pint | Dec. 23, 2026 – Dec. 30, 2026 |
| Strawberry | Quart & Pint | Dec. 23, 2026 – Dec. 30, 2026 |
| Cookie Dough | Pint | Dec. 23, 2026 – Dec. 30, 2026 |
| Dutch Chocolate | Quart | Dec. 23, 2026 – Dec. 30, 2026 |
| Mint Chip | Pint | Dec. 23, 2026 – Dec. 30, 2026 |
(Note: For Mint Chip Pints, the specific UPC code to check is 7-84830-10050-4).
Which States Are Included in the Straus Recall?
The recalled ice cream was distributed to retailers and placed on store shelves starting May 4, 2026. If you bought your ice cream before this date, your product is not part of this specific batch.
Currently, the recall covers supermarkets and retailers in these 17 states:
- Arizona (AZ)
- California (CA)
- Colorado (CO)
- Connecticut (CT)
- Florida (FL)
- Georgia (GA)
- Iowa (IA)
- Illinois (IL)
- Indiana (IN)
- Maryland (MD)
- New Jersey (NJ)
- Oregon (OR)
- Pennsylvania (PA)
- South Carolina (SC)
- Texas (TX)
- Washington (WA)
- Wisconsin (WI)
Pro Tip: Identify your state. Ensure your state is actually on the FDA list. If you bought the ice cream in New York, for instance, it is not part of the 17-state distribution zone for this recall.
How to Check Your Straus Ice Cream Carton
Do not look at the lid to verify your product. The critical “Best By” date is printed in black ink directly on the outside bottom of the paper cup.
Common Mistake: Throwing away safe ice cream because you misread the size. The recall is highly specific to package sizes.
For example, imagine a family in Texas has a Quart of Straus Cookie Dough ice cream. They check the FDA alert and realize only Pints of Cookie Dough were recalled. Their Quart is safe to consume. Checking both the size and the date prevents unnecessary food waste.
Pro Tip: Check the size carefully. Dutch Chocolate is only recalled in Quarts, while Cookie Dough is only recalled in Pints. Always cross-reference the exact size printed on the front of your carton with the rapid identification matrix above.
What to Do If You Have Recalled Ice Cream (3-Step Checklist)
If you confirm your ice cream is part of the recall, you need to act quickly. Grocery retailers cannot process refunds for this specific situation at the customer service desk. Instead, the manufacturer is handling all compensation directly.
Follow this simple 3-step checklist to get your replacement.
Step 1: Photograph the Evidence Take a clear picture of the bottom of the container. Make sure the black “Best By” date and the UPC code are visible. You will need this exact information to fill out the replacement voucher form. Pro Tip: Take a photo before trashing the carton. Once it is in the garbage, you lose your proof of purchase.
Step 2: Discard Safely Throw the affected carton directly into your household trash. Do not try to salvage any part of it. The FDA is clear on this point: “Consumers who have purchased the recalled product are urged to discard the product.”
Step 3: Request Your Voucher Do not drive back to the supermarket. Straus Family Creamery is offering product replacement vouchers through a digital process instead of cash refunds. Go online and fill out the official form. [Straus Family Creamery Official Recall Form]
Mid-Article Summary
- Check the bottom: Look for black ink dates between Dec. 23 and Dec. 30, 2026.
- Take a photo: Capture the date and UPC code for your records.
- Throw it away: Do not eat the ice cream or return it to the store.
- Get a voucher: Submit your photo and details online to get a replacement.
- Safe products: If your dates or sizes do not match the recall list exactly, your ice cream is safe to eat.
Why Was the Ice Cream Recalled?
The recall was triggered by the potential presence of metal fragments inside the ice cream. Physical hazards like metal can cause dental damage or internal injury if swallowed.
Straus Family Creamery initiated this action voluntarily. According to official FDA statements, “The company is taking this action out of an abundance of caution and has implemented appropriate corrective actions.”
As of mid-May 2026, no injuries related to eating the recalled ice cream have been reported.
Pro Tip: Clean your freezer shelf. Even though this is a metal fragment recall and not a bacterial threat like Listeria, it is always a good safety habit to wipe down the freezer area where you stored a recalled product.
Customer Service & Form Issues
Sometimes digital forms fail or ask for information you cannot read clearly on your carton. If you have trouble accessing the online voucher form, or if the printed date is smudged, reach out to the company directly.
Pro Tip: Contact support for form issues. You can bypass the digital form by emailing your product details and photos to support@strausmilk.com. You can also call their customer service line at 1-707-776-2887.
End Summary
Food recalls can be alarming, but handling this one is straightforward. Check your freezer for the five specific flavors (Vanilla Bean, Strawberry, Cookie Dough, Dutch Chocolate, and Mint Chip). Verify the exact sizes and the late-December 2026 “Best By” dates. If you have a recalled carton, snap a photo, throw the ice cream away, and claim your voucher online.
Your Next Steps:
- Check your cartons against the rapid identification matrix.
- Photograph the bottom date and UPC if it matches the recall.
- Fill out the official Straus Family Creamery voucher form online.
FAQs
Can I return recalled Straus ice cream to Whole Foods or my local grocery store?
No. Consumers are advised not to return the recalled ice cream to the store where it was purchased. The manufacturer requires you to throw it away and request a voucher online.
Are all Straus Family Creamery products recalled?
No. Only specific pints and quarts of five flavors (Vanilla Bean, Strawberry, Cookie Dough, Dutch Chocolate, Mint Chip) with “Best By” dates between Dec. 23 and Dec. 30, 2026, are affected.
What happens if I accidentally ate the recalled ice cream?
As of mid-May 2026, no injuries related to the consumption of the recalled ice cream have been reported. If you consumed it and feel unwell, or suspect you swallowed a foreign object, contact a healthcare professional immediately.
Where is the best by date on a Straus ice cream pint?
The date is printed in black ink on the outside bottom of the paper cup, not on the lid.
Is Straus milk or butter affected by this recall?
No. This specific recall only applies to the select flavors and sizes of Organic Super Premium Ice Cream listed in the FDA alert.
How long does it take to get a replacement voucher?
Verified timelines for voucher delivery are not currently available in the official recall notice. Contact Straus customer service directly at support@strausmilk.com for delivery estimates.
Will I get a cash refund for the recalled ice cream?
No. Straus Family Creamery is offering replacement product vouchers rather than direct cash refunds.
References
- Food and Drug Administration (FDA), 2026
- Straus Family Creamery, 2026
